Explanatory Notes        Apparatus Notes ()
This text has been superseded by a newly published text
MTPDocEd
To William Dean Howells
9 August 1876 • Elmira, N.Y. (MS: NN-BGC, UCCL 02503)
(SUPERSEDED)
My Dear Howells:

I was just about to write you, when your letter came—& not on one of those obscene postal cards, either, but reverently, upon paper.1explanatory note

I shall read that biography, though the letter of acceptance was amply sufficient to corral my vote without any further knowledge of the man.2explanatory note Which reminds me that a campaign club in Jersey City wrote a few days ago & invited me to be present at the raising of a Tilden & Hendricks flag there & take the stand & give them some “counsel.” Well, I could not go, but gave them counsel & advice by letter, & in the kindliest terms as to the raising of the flag—advised them “not to raise it.”

Get your book out quick, for this is a momentous time. If Tilden is elected I think the entire country will go pretty straight to the bad Mrs. Howells’s bad place.

I am infringing on your patent—I started a record of our children’s sayings, last night. Which reminds me that last week I sent down & got Susie a vast pair of shoes of a most villainous pattern, for I discovered that her feet were being twisted & cramped out of shape by a smaller & prettier article. She did not complain, but looked only degraded & injured. At night her mamma gave her the usual advice admonition when she was about to say her prayers—to-wit:

“Now, Susie—think about God.”

“Mamma, I can’t, with these shoes.”3explanatory note

The farm is perfectly delightful, this season. It is as quiet & peaceful as a South-sea island. Some of the sun-sets which we have witnessed from this commanding eminence were marvelous. One evening a rainbow spanned an entire range of hills with its mighty arch, & from a black hub resting upon the hill-top under top in the exact centre, black rays diverged upward in perfect regularity to the rainbow’s arch & created a very strongly defined & altogether the most majestic, magnificent, & startling half-sunk wagon wheel you can imagine. After that, a world of p tumbling & prodigious clouds came drifting up out of the west & took to themselves a wonderfully rich & brilliant green color—the decided green of new spring foliage. Close by them we saw the intense blue of the skies, through rents in the cloud-rack, & away off in another quarter were drifting clouds of a delicate pink color. In one place was han hung a pall of dense black clouds, like compacted pitch-smoke. And the stupendous wagon wheel was still in the supremacy of its unspeakable grandeur. So you see, the colors present in the sky at one & the same time were blue, green, pink, black, & the varicoloredemendation splendors of the rainbow. All strong & decided colors, too. I don’t know whether this wierdemendation & astounding spectacle most suggested heaven, or hell. The wonder, with its constant, striking, stately, & always surprising changes, lasted upwards of two hours, & we all stood on the top of our the hill by my study till the final miracle was complete & the greatest day ended that we ever saw. in margin: Our farmer, who is a grave man, observed watched that spectacle to the end, & then observed that it was “dam funny.” 4explanatory note

The double-barreled novel lies torpid. I found I could not go on with it. The chapters I had written were still too new & familiar to me.5explanatory note I may take it up next winter, but cannot tell yet. I waited & waited, to see if my interest in it would not revive, but gave it up a month ago & began another boys’ book—more to be at work than anything else. I have written 400 pages on it—therefore it is very nearly half done. It is Huck Finn’s Autobiography. I like it only tolerably well, as far as I have got, & may possibly pigeon-holeemendation or burn the MS when it is done.

So the comedy is done, & with a “fair degree of satisfaction.” That rejoices me, & makes me mad, too—for I can’t plan a comedy, & what have you done that God should be so good to you? I have racked myself baldheaded trying to plan a comedy-harness for some promising characters of mine to work in, & had to give it up. It is a noble lot of blooded stock & worth no end of money, but they must stand in the stable & be profl itless. I want to be present when the comedy is produced, & help enjoy the success.6explanatory note

Warner’semendation book is mighty readable, I think.7explanatory note Love to ye’s.

Yrs Ever
Mark.

Mrs. Clemens sends her love & warm regards to the two of you respectively. That is what I understood her to mean.


You better give that campaign book to Bliss—but don’t tell Houghton I suggested it. It’s my sentiments, though.8explanatory note

Textual Commentary
Previous Publication:

MTL , 1:281–83; MTHL , 1:143–45.

Provenance:

See Howells Letters in Description of Provenanceclick to open letter.

Explanatory Notes
1 

Clemens answered the following letter (CU-MARK):

editorial office of the atlantic monthly. the riverside press, cambridge, mass.
My dear Clemens:

I wrote you a long and affectionate letter just before you left Hartford, and you replied with a postal card; on which, instantly forgetting all the past kindnesses between us, I dropped you. You may not have known it but I did. Now I find I can’t very well get on without hearing from you, and I wish you would give me your news—what you are doing, thinking, saying. We went first to our Shaker place in Shirley Village, but that proved a wonderful failure, and ten days ̭ago̭ we came away to this place—Townsend Harbor, Mass.,—where we find ourselves in the utmost clover, and where we propose to stay till November.—I’ve just finished my comedy, “Out of the Question,” with a fair degree of satisfaction, and now I’m about to begin a campaign life of Hayes, which Mr. Houghton wants to publish. (You know I wrote the life of Lincoln which elected him.) I expect that it will sell; at any rate I like the man, and shall like doing it. Gen. Hayes is Mrs. Howells cousin, and she thinks that any one who votes for Tilden will go to the Bad Place.

What are you doing with your double-barrel novel? Now that books are so dreadfully dead, why don’t you think of selling it to the Atlantic for next year? Mr. Houghton wants me to ask you to name a price, and he promises to prosecute any body who copies it.

My wife joins me in cordial regards to Mrs. Clemens.

Yours ever
W. D. Howells.

For Howells’s “long and affectionate letter” see 12 and 14 May 76 to Howellsclick to open letter, n. 6. Clemens’s postcard reply to it is not known to survive. Out of the Question was serialized in the Atlantic Monthly from February through May 1877 and was published in late April 1877 as a book. Howells’s Life of Abraham Lincoln had been published on 5 June 1860 by Follett, Foster and Company. His Sketch of the Life and Character of Rutherford B. Hayes was published on 15 September 1876 by Henry H. Houghton and Company. In 1875 Houghton had tried to persuade Clemens to serialize Tom Sawyer in the Atlantic Monthly before its publication as a book. Houghton had promised then, as he did again now, to forestall the newspaper reprintings that reduced magazine as well as book sales (see L6 , 339–40 n. 1, 503–5; Howells 1860; Howells 1876; Howells 1877; Howells 1877; Howells 1979, 75 n. 3, 375; Howells 1979, 137 n. 1).

3 

Clemens included this incident in “A Record of The Small Foolishnesses of Susie & ‘Bay’ Clemens (Infants.),” which he continued to compile through 7 June 1885 (SLC 1876–85, 21).

4 

John T. Lewis (1835–1906), born in Carroll County, Maryland, where he lived as a black freeman, had settled in Elmira in 1864. He worked as a coachman for Jervis Langdon, then as a blacksmith, and was now the tenant farmer at Quarry Farm (Thomasson 1985, 17, 19).

5 

Possibly the unidentified work Clemens had begun in November 1875 (see L6 , 585 n. 9).

6 

Out of the Question was never produced (Howells 1960, 34; Howells 1979, 206).

7 

Mummies and Moslems .

8 

Sales of the biography of Hayes did not meet Howells’s expectations (see 11 Oct 76 to Howellsclick to open letter, n. 1).

Emendations and Textual Notes
  varicolored •  vari- | colored
  wierd •  sic
  pigeon-hole •  pigeon- | hole
  success. [¶] Warner’s •  success.— | [¶] Warner’s