Explanatory Notes
See Headnote
Apparatus Notes
See Headnotes
CHAPTER 47
[begin page 308]

CHAPTER 47

Somebody has said that in order to know a community, one must observe the style of its funerals and know what manner of men they bury with most ceremony. I cannot say which class we buried with most eclat in our “flush times,” the distinguished public benefactor or the distinguished rough—possibly the two chief grades or grand divisions of society honored their illustrious dead about equally; and hence, no doubt the philosopher I have quoted from would have needed to see two representative funerals in Virginia before forming his estimate of the people.

There was a grand time over Buck Fanshaw when he died. He was a representative citizen. He had “killed his man”—not in his own quarrel, it is true, but in defence of a stranger unfairly beset by numbers. He had kept a sumptuous saloon. He had been the proprietor of a dashing helpmeet whom he could have discarded without the formality of a divorce. He had held a high position in the fire departmentexplanatory note and been a very Warwick in politicsexplanatory note. When he died there was great lamentation throughout the town, but especially in the vast bottom-stratum of society.

On the inquest it was shown that Buck Fanshaw, in the delirium of a wasting typhoid fever, had taken arsenic, shot himself through the body, cut his throat, and jumped out of a four-story window and broken his neck—and after due deliberation, the jury, sad and tearful, but with intelligence unblinded by its sorrow, brought in a verdict of death “by the visitation of God.”explanatory note What could the world do without juries?

Prodigious preparations were made for the funeral. All the vehicles in town were hired, all the saloons put in mourning, all the municipal and fire-company flags hung at half-mast, and all the firemen ordered to muster in uniform and bring their machines duly draped in black. Now—let us remark in parenthesis—as all [begin page 309] the peoples of the earth had representative adventurers in the Silverland, and as each adventurer had brought the slang of his nation or his locality with him, the combination made the slang of Nevada the richest and the most infinitely varied and copious that had ever existed anywhere in the world, perhaps, except in the mines of California in the “early days.” Slang was the language of Nevada. It was hard to preach a sermon without it, and be understood. Such phrases as “You bet!” “Oh, no, I reckon not!” “No Irish need apply,” and a hundred others, became so common as to fall from the lips of a speaker unconsciously—and very often when they did not touch the subject under discussion and consequently failed to mean anything.

committeeman and minister.

After Buck Fanshaw’s inquest, a meeting of the short-haired brotherhoodexplanatory note was held, for nothing can be done on the Pacific coast without a public meeting and an expression of sentiment. Regretful resolutionsemendation were passed and various committees appointed; among others, a committee of one was deputed to call on the minister, a fragile, gentle, spirituelemendation new fledgling from an eastern theological seminary, and as yet unacquainted with the ways of the minesexplanatory note. The committeeman, “Scotty” Briggs, made his visitexplanatory note; and in after days it was worth something to hear the minister tell about [begin page 310] it. Scotty was a stalwart rough, whose customary suit, when on weighty official business, like committee work, was a fire helmet, flaming red flannel shirt, patent-leatheremendation belt with spanner and revolver attached, coat hung over arm, and pants stuffed into boot-topsemendation. He formed something of a contrast to the pale theological student. It is fair to say of Scotty, however, in passing, that he had a warm heart, and a strong love for his friends, and never entered into a quarrel when he could reasonably keep out of it. Indeed, it was commonly said that whenever one of Scotty’s fights was investigated, it always turned out that it had originally been no affair of his, but that out of native goodheartedness he had dropped in of his own accord to help the man who was getting the worst of it. He and Buck Fanshaw were bosom friends, for years, and had often taken adventurous “pot luckemendation” together. On one occasion, they had thrown off their coats and taken the weaker side in a fight among strangers, and after gaining a hard-earned victory, turned and found that the men they were helping had deserted early, and not only that, but had stolen their coats and made off with them! But to return to Scotty’s visit to the minister. He was on a sorrowful mission, now, and his face was the picture of woe. Being admitted to the presence he sat down before the clergyman, placed his firehat on an unfinished manuscript sermon under the minister’s nose, took from it a red silk handkerchief, wiped his brow and heaved a sigh of dismal impressiveness, explanatory of his business. He choked, and even shed tears; but with an effort he mastered his voice and said in lugubrious tones:

“Are you the duck that runs the gospel-mill next door?”

“Am I the—pardon me, I believe I do not understand?”

With another sigh and a half-sob, Scotty rejoined:

“Why you see we are in a bit of trouble, and the boys thought maybe you would give us a lift, if we’d tackle you—that is, if I’ve got the rights of it and you are the head clerk of the doxology-works next door.”

“I am the shepherd in charge of the flock whose fold is next door.”

“The which?”

“The spiritual adviser of the little company of believers whose sanctuary adjoins these premises.”

Scotty scratched his head, reflected a moment, and then said:

[begin page 311] “You ruther hold over me, pard. I reckon I can’t call that hand. Ante and pass the buck.”

“How? I beg pardon. What did I understand you to say?”

“Well, you’ve ruther got the bulge on me. Or maybe we’ve both got the bulge, somehow. You don’t smoke me and I don’t smoke you. You see, one of the boys has passed in his checks and we want to give him a good send-off, and so the thing I’m on now is to roust out somebody to jerk a little chin-music for us and waltz him through handsome.”

“My friend, I seem to grow more and more bewildered. Your observations are wholly incomprehensible to me. Cannot you simplify them in some way? At first I thought perhaps I understood you, but I grope now. Would it not expedite matters if you restricted yourself to categorical statements of fact unencumbered with obstructing accumulations of metaphor and allegory?”

Another pause, and more reflection. Then, said Scotty:

“I’ll have to pass, I judge.”

“How?”

“You’ve raised me out, pard.”

“I still fail to catch your meaning.”

“Why, that last lead of yourn is too many for me—that’s the idea. I can’t neither trump nor follow suit.”

The clergyman sank back in his chair perplexed. Scotty leaned his head on his hand and gave himself up to thought. Presently his face came up, sorrowful but confident.

“I’ve got it now, so’s you can savvy,” he said. “What we want is a gospel-sharp. See?”

“A what?”

“Gospel-sharp. Parson.”

“Oh! Why did you not say so before? I am a clergyman—a parson.”

“Now you talk! You see my blind and straddle it like a man. Put it there!”—extending a brawny paw, which closed over the minister’s small hand and gave it a shake indicative of fraternal sympathy and fervent gratification.

“Now we’re all right, pard. Let’s start fresh. Don’t you mind my snuffling a little—becuz we’re in a power of trouble. You see, one of the boys has gone up the flume—”

“Gone where?”

[begin page 312] “Up the flume—throwed up the sponge, you understand.”

“Thrown up the sponge?”

“Yes—kicked the bucket—”

“Ah—has departed to that mysterious country from whose bourne no traveler returns.”

“Return! I reckon not. Why pard, he’s dead!

“Yes, I understand.”

“Oh, you do? Well I thought maybe you might be getting tangled some more. Yes, you see he’s dead again—”

Again? Why, has he ever been dead before?”

“Dead before? No! Do you reckon a man has got as many lives as a cat? But you bet you he’s awful dead now, poor old boy, and I wish I’d never seen this day. I don’t want no better friend than Buck Fanshaw. I knowed him by the back; and when I know a man and like him, I freeze to him—you hear me. Take him all round, pard, there never was a bullier man in the mines. No man ever knowed Buck Fanshaw to go back on a friend. But it’s all up, you know, it’s all up. It ain’t no use. They’ve scooped him.”

“Scooped him?”

“Yes—death has. Well, well, well, we’ve got to give him up. Yes indeed. It’s a kind of a hard world, after all, ain’t it? But pard, he was a rustler! You ought to seen him get started once. He was a bully boy with a glass eye! Just spit in his face and give him room according to his strength, and it was just beautiful to see him peel and go in. He was the worst son of a thief that ever drawed breath. Pard, he was on it! He was on it bigger than an Injun!”

“On it? On what?”

“On the shoot. On the shoulder. On the fight, you understand. He didn’t give a continental for anybody. Beg your pardon, friend, for coming so near saying a cuss-word—but you see I’m on an awful strain, in this palaver, on account of having to cramp down and draw everything so mild. But we’ve got to give him up. There ain’t any getting around that, I don’t reckon. Now if we can get you to help plant him—”

“Preach the funeral discourse? Assist at the obsequies?”

“Obs’quies is good. Yes. That’s it—that’s our little game. We are going to get the thing up regardless, you know. He was always nifty himself, and so you bet you his funeral ain’t going to be no [begin page 313] slouch—solid silver door-plate on his coffin, six plumes on the hearse, and a nigger on the box in a biled shirt and a plug hat—how’s that for high? And we’ll take care of you, pard. We’ll fix you all right. There’ll be a kerridge for you; and whatever you want, you just ’scape out and we’ll ’tend to it. We’ve got a shebang fixed up for you to stand behind, in No. 1’s house, and don’t you be afraid. Just go in and toot your horn, if you don’t sell a clam. Put Buck through as bully as you can, pard, for anybody that knowed him will tell you that he was one of the whitest men that was ever in the mines. You can’t draw it too strong. He never could stand it to see things going wrong. He’s done more to make this town quiet and peaceable than any man in it. I’ve seen him lick four Greasers in eleven minutes, myself. If a thing wanted regulating, he warn’t

scotty regulating matters.
a man to go browsing around after somebody to do it, but he would prance in and regulate it himself. He warn’t a Catholic. Scasely. He was down on ’em. His word was, ‘No Irish need apply!’ But it didn’t make no difference about that when it came down to what a man’s rights was—and so, when some roughs jumped the Catholic bone- [begin page 314] yard and started in to stake out town lotsexplanatory note emendation in it he went for ’em! And he cleaned ’em, too! I was there, pard, and I seen it myself.”

“That was very well indeed—at least the impulse was—whether the act was strictly defensible or not. Had deceased any religious convictions? That is to say, did he feel a dependence upon, or acknowledge allegiance to a higher power?”emendation

More reflection.

“I reckon you’ve stumped me again, pard. Could you say it over once more, and say it slow?”

“Well, to simplify it somewhat, was he, or rather had he ever been connected with any organization sequestered from secular concerns and devoted to self-sacrifice in the interests of morality?”

“All down but nine—set ’em up on the other alley, pard.”

“What did I understand you to say?”

“Why, you’re most too many for me, you know. When you get in with your left I hunt grass every time. Every time you draw, you fill; but I don’t seem to have any luck. Let’semendation have a new deal.”

“How? Begin again?”

“That’s it.”

“Very well. Was he a good man, and—”

“There—I see that; don’t put up another chip till I look at my hand. A good man, says you? Pard, it ain’t no name for it. He was the best man that ever—pard, you would have doted on that man. He could lam any galoot of his inches in America. It was him that put down the riot last election before it got a start; and everybody said he was the only man that could have done it. He waltzed in with a spanner in one hand and a trumpet in the other, and sent fourteen men home on a shutter in less than three minutesexplanatory note. He had that riot all broke up and prevented nice before anybody ever got a chance to strike a blow. He was always for peace, and he would have peace—he could not stand disturbances. Pard, he was a great loss to this town. It would please the boys if you could chip in something like that and do him justice. Here once when the Micks got to throwing stones through the Methodis’ Sunday school windows, Buck Fanshaw, all of his own notion, shut up his saloon and took a couple of six-shooters and mounted guard over the Sunday school. Says he, ‘No Irish need apply!’ And they didn’t. He was the bulliest man in the mountains, pard! He could run [begin page 315] faster, jump higher, hit harder, and hold more tangle-foot whisky without spilling it than any man in seventeen counties. Put that in, pard—it’ll please the boys more than anything you could say. And you can say, pard, that he never shook his mother.”

“Never shook his mother?”

neveremendation shook his mother.

“That’s it—any of the boys will tell you so.”

“Well, but why should he shake her?”

“That’s what I say—but some people does.”

“Not people of any repute?”

“Well, some that averages pretty so-so.”

“In my opinion the man that would offer personal violence to his own mother, ought to—”

“Cheese it, pard; you’ve banked your ball clean outside the string. What I was a drivin’ at, was, that he never throwed off on his mother—don’t you see? No indeedy. He give her a house to live in, and town lots, and plenty of money; and he looked after her and took care of her all the time; and when she was down with the small-pox I’m d—d if he didn’t set up nights and nuss her himself! Beg your pardon for saying it, but it hopped out too quick for yours truly. You’ve treated me like a gentleman, pard, and I ain’t the man to hurt your feelings intentional. I think you’reemendation white. I think [begin page 316] you’re a square man, pard. I like you, and I’ll lick any man that don’t. I’ll lick him till he can’t tell himself from a last year’s corpse! Put it there!” [Another fraternal hand-shakeemendation—and exit.]

The obsequies were all that “the boys” could desire. Such a marvel of funeral pomp had never been seen in Virginia. The plumed hearse, the dirge-breathing brass bands, the closed marts of business, the flags drooping at half-mastemendation, the long, plodding procession of uniformed secret societies, military battalions and fire companies, draped engines, carriages of officials, and citizens in vehicles and on foot, attracted multitudes of spectators to the sidewalks, roofs and windows; and for years afterward, the degree of grandeur attained by any civic display in Virginia was determined by comparison with Buck Fanshaw’s funeral.

Scotty Briggs, as a pall-bearer and a mourner, occupied a prominent place at the funeral, and when the sermon was finished and the last sentence of the prayer for the dead man’s soul ascended, he responded, in a low voice, but with feeling:

Amen. No Irish need apply.”

As the bulk of the response was without apparent relevancy, it was probably nothing more than a humble tribute to the memory of the friend that was gone; for, as Scotty had once said, it was “his word.”

scotty as a sunday school emendation teacher.

Scotty Briggs, in after days, achieved the distinction of becoming the only convert to religion that was ever gathered from the Virginia roughs; and it transpired that the man who had it in him [begin page 317] to espouse the quarrel of the weak out of inborn nobility of spirit was no mean timber whereof to construct a Christian. The making him one did not warp his generosity or diminish his courage; on the contrary it gave intelligent direction to the one and a broader field to the other. If his Sunday schoolemendation class progressed faster than the other classes, was it matter for wonder? I think not. He talked to his pioneer small fryemendation in a language they understood! It was my large privilege, a month before he died, to hear him tell the beautiful story of Joseph and his brethren to his class “without looking at the book.” I leave it to the reader to fancy what it was like, as it fell, riddled with slang, from the lips of that grave, earnest teacher, and was listened to by his little learners with a consuming interest that showed that they were as unconscious as he was that any violence was being done to the sacred proprieties!

Editorial Emendations CHAPTER 47
  resolutions (C)  •  resolutious (A) 
  gentle, spirituel (C)  •  gentle ,spirituel (A) 
  patent-leather (C)  •  patent leather (A) 
  boot-tops (C)  •  boot tops (A) 
  pot luck (C)  •  pot-luck (A) 
  town lots (C)  •  town-lots (A) 
  power?” (C)  •  power?’ (A) 
  Let’s (C)  •  Lets (A) 
  never  (C)  •  didn’t  (A) 
  you’re (C)  •  you ’re (A) 
  hand-shake (C)  •  hand-  |  shake (A) 
  half-mast (C)  •  half mast (A) 
  sunday school  (C)  •  sunday-school  (A) 
  Sunday school (C)  •  Sunday-school (A) 
  small fry (C)  •  small-fry (A) 
Explanatory Notes CHAPTER 47
 grand time over Buck Fanshaw when he died . . . high position in the fire department] The prototype of Buck Fanshaw was Thomas Peasley, a well-known Virginia City figure. Born in New York, Peasley went to Virginia City from Calaveras County, California, in 1860 and became the owner of the city’s most elegant and popular saloon, the Sazerac. He helped to organize the city’s volunteer fire department, and in 1862 became its first chief engineer. The charismatic and athletic Peasley was also the “proprietor,” as Mark Twain puts it, of Julia Bulette, Virginia City’s first and most famous courtesan, and made her the “queen,” in full fire regalia, of Engine Company No. 1. An aggressive Unionist, he was widely acknowledged as a leader both in local and national political campaigns in Virginia City. He had “killed his man,” a young tough named “Sugarfoot Jack” Jenkins, although not in defense of a stranger (see the note at 323.17). By 1866 Peasley had given up his saloon business and become manager and coproprietor of Maguire’s Opera House and sergeant-at-arms of the Nevada State Senate. On 2 February 1866 Peasley, aged about thirty-eight, engaged in a gunfight with Martin V. Barnhart in the bar of the Ormsby House in Carson City, which resulted in the death of both men. Obituary notices called Peasley the “acknowledged political head of the Fire and Police Departments of Virginia, and . . . a man of great influence with the sports and roughs,” and asserted that the vote of the “Peasley crowd” was essential to a politician’s success. Peasley’s body was removed to Virginia City, where a resplendent and well-attended funeral was held. Clemens remained in San Francisco at the time (“Two Men Killed, in Carson,” San Francisco Morning Call, 3 Feb 66, 3; “A Terrible Tragedy,” Carson City Appeal, 3 Feb 66, 2; “Funeral Yesterday,” Virginia City Union, 5 Feb 66, 3; ET&S1 , 473–74; Angel, 599; Lyman, 119–22; Mack 1947, 195–98; Beebe and Clegg, 16–18).
 a very Warwick in politics] Richard Neville (1428–71), earl of Warwick and Salisbury, was known as “the Kingmaker” during the early years of the Wars of the Roses. He helped Edward, duke of York, to secure the English throne in 1461 as Edward IV, and served as his powerful great chamberlain. Falling out with Edward, he drove him from the throne, and in 1470 restored Henry VI of the house of Lancaster.
 

a verdict of death “by the visitation of God.”] Clemens included a similar anecdote in his “People and Things” column in the Buffalo Express for 18 August 1869:

[begin page 669] In Nevada, a man with the consumption took the small-pox from a negro, the cholera from a Chinaman, and the yellow fever and the erysipelas from other parties, and swallowed fifteen grains of strychnine and fell out of the third-story window and broke his neck. Verdict of the jury, “Died by the visitation of God.” (SLC 1869d)

 the short-haired brotherhood] The term “short hairs” was apparently used for “roughs” in general, because they wore their hair in a short “fighting cut.” From the mid-1860s the expression was sometimes used in politics to designate the party or faction of the “common man or ‘toughs’ ” (Winfield J. Davis, 213–14; Morton, 111; Mathews, 2:1530).
 minister . . . as yet unacquainted with the ways of the mines] Mark Twain’s portrait of the young minister—here and in his earlier Enterprise piece (see the next note)—was based on his friend the Reverend Franklin S. Rising (1833?–68), the rector of St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Virginia City. (Rising did not, however, conduct the religious service at Peasley’s funeral: the Reverend William M. Martin of Virginia City’s Presbyterian Church officiated.) Rising arrived in Virginia City from New York in April 1862, formally opened his new church the following February, and helped establish Episcopal parishes in neighboring cities. He resigned his position in 1866 because of poor health and traveled to the Sandwich Islands, where he met Clemens again. The two men returned to the States together in July 1866 on the clipper Smyrniote. Hearing of Rising’s death in an Ohio River steamboat collision in December 1868, Clemens described his association with this “noble young fellow” in a letter to Olivia Langdon: “I used to try to teach him how he ought to preach in order to get at the better natures of the rough population about him, & he used to try hard to learn—for I knew them & he did not, for he was refined & sensitive & not intended for such a people as that” ( L2 , 333, 337 n. 2; L1 , 352, 354 n. 3; Doten, 2:877; Angel, 199–202, 215).
 

The committeeman, “Scotty” Briggs, made his visit] Mark Twain apparently returned to one of his early Enterprise pieces for the germ of his description of Scotty Briggs’s interview with the minister. This recently discovered Enterprise article survives only in part, as a paraphrase quoted in the San Francisco Call and Post of 1 April 1921, and is reprinted here for the first time. The author of the article explained that Clemens had been dispatched by Goodman to interview the clergymen of the area; he “began with the Baptist Church, at Gold Hill,” and reported as follows:

The high price charged for water by the water company renders it impossible to immerse any but wealthy converts. For this and other reasons the pastor of the church informs me that he will be compelled to resign. His salary is small, only $24 a month. But the irregularity with which it is paid, or, to speak more accurately, the regularity with which it is not paid, is very distressing to him. He [begin page 670] keeps bachelor’s quarters and is in debt to his butcher, and when the preacher calls for a beefsteak the butcher, in a sort of absent-minded way cuts him off a piece of liver. His congregation has dwindled to nine regular attendants, eight of whom are women, and his collection last Sabbath amounted to only twenty cents. On the whole it may be said that the condition of the cause of Christ in Gold Hill leaves very much to be desired.

The Methodist Church, in Virginia City, presents different conditions. The congregation is large and contributions are liberal. The pastor is a broad man—as broad as he is long. He measures 62 inches around the waist and 62 inches from keel to main yard.

The Episcopal clergyman is a charming little gentleman just out from the effete East. He is as unlearned in sporting nomenclature as sporting men are unlearned in the technicalities of orthodoxy.

Last week, on the day before Andy Brown died, his brother Steve went to the Episcopal clergyman and said: “My brother is about to pass in his checks and he wants you to come down to the joint and start him off square before he becomes a stiff.”

“I am not a banker,” said the clergyman, “and I can not aid your brother in passing checks.”

“You don’t tumble,” said Andy. “My brother is going to die, and he wants you to do some praying over him before he goes. He doesn’t feel sure as to where he will land, and he thinks that your prayers might keep him out of a hot climate.”

“I see,” said the divine. “Is your brother a professor?”

“He was,” said Andy, “but since Baldy Thompson licked him in their last fight he has given up the profession of pugilism.”

“Do you think,” said the clergyman, “that your brother would like the Eucharist administered?”

“Well, partner,” said Andy, dubiously, “it looks to me like a queer time for that sort of thing. But you know best, and you can take your deck along or I’ll get you a pack of cards at the saloon.” (Wells 1921a)

Mark Twain’s portrait of Scotty Briggs, like his Buck Fanshaw, undoubtedly owed some of its features to actual Nevada figures. Briggs may have been drawn from John Van Buren (Jack) Perry, Virginia City’s popular marshal and, like his friend Thomas Peasley, an ardent Unionist and a mainstay of the Virginia Volunteer Fire Department. Just as Scotty Briggs brawled alongside of Buck Fanshaw, so Perry joined Peasley and other Unionists in defending a Union recruiter attacked by a Secessionist in a Virginia City street. Mark Twain at least twice made reference to Perry’s mastery of “vulgar phraseology” and recorded examples of his vivid slang quite similar to those of his fictional counterpart (SLC 1863c, 1863m). George Wharton James, an intimate friend of Perry’s, claimed that Clemens became “very fond” of the marshal and spent many hours listening to his stories: “It was Jack who told several of the stories that appear in ‘Roughing It’ ” (James, 530). Steve Gillis (see the note at 323.30–325.2), in later years, claimed that Scotty Briggs was drawn from one Ruef Williams, a neighbor at Jackass Hill in Tuolumne County—and possibly the “Riff Williams” whom Goodman mentioned as one of Peasley and Perry’s cronies in the Virginia Fire Department. Nothing further is known about Williams, except that he was probably the “M. R. Williams” who was chief of the department at [begin page 671] the time of Peasley’s death (“A Card,” Virginia City Union, 5 Feb 66, 2; Angel, 266, 600; AD, 26 May 1907, CU-MARK, in MTE , 361; Fulton, 55; Goodman 1892a).

 

some roughs jumped the Catholic bone-yard and started in to stake out town lots] The Enterprise local (possibly Clemens) reported on 25 December 1862:

On Saturday last, parties in this city took possession of the Catholic cemetery, located in the southeast part of the town, and commenced the work of fencing it in and building thereon a house. When this became known throughout the city, there came near being a most bloody row over the matter. Many armed themselves and were for proceeding instantly to the burying ground to drive the jumpers away by force of arms.

But peaceful counsel prevailed, while a decision regarding ownership of the ground was awaited (“Jumping a Graveyard at Washoe,” San Francisco Evening Bulletin, 29 Dec 62, 1, reprinting the Virginia City Territorial Enterprise of 25 December).

 

It was him that put down the riot last election . . . in less than three minutes] Paul Fatout has suggested that the model for this free-for-all was not an election riot, but a brawl that broke out between two rival fire companies after a major fire in Virginia City on 28 August 1863. The Virginia City Union reported:

Fire Companies Nos. 1 and 2 met at the intersection of Taylor and C streets, and by some means became involved in a general row. . . . Trumpets, sticks and faucets were freely used, and blood streamed from numerous heads. The efforts of the police to stop it were at first futile, the Marshal himself i.e., Perry receiving a severe blow on the head with a club. (“The Fire at Virginia, N. T.,” Sacramento Union, 31 Aug 63, 4, reprinting the Virginia City Union of 29 August)

Clemens reported on the fire and the riot in a dispatch to the San Francisco Morning Call (SLC 1863o). In composing this chapter, he may have conflated the riot with an incident in which Peasley made a lone stand before an anti-Union election rally in Virginia City on 22 October 1864:

Fiery speeches and a street parade were features of the demonstration. As the parade neared the International Hotel, . . . Tom Peasley advanced to the middle of the street, faced the leaders of the line, which numbered thousands, and leveled two six-shooters at their heads. They came to an abrupt halt. Peasley pointed to a picture of President Lincoln that had been suspended from a window of the hotel, head downward, to indicate the derision of the anti-Unionists for the president.

He demanded that the picture be righted, and the parade leaders, “knowing the deadly earnestness of the man, and not caring to trifle with one of his reputation,” complied; “only then did Peasley step aside and give the word for the parade to move on” (Levison, 7; “An Insult,” Virginia City Union, 23 Oct 64, 3; Fatout 1964, 81–82).