Explanatory Notes
Apparatus Notes
MTPDocEd
[begin page 343]
71. An Excellent School
12 February 1864

This sketch forms the second section of a “Letter from Mark Twain” written from Carson City on Friday, 5 February 1864, and published in the Virginia City Territorial Enterprise on February 12.1

The school described in this sketch, conducted by William B. Lawlor, was one of two private schools in Carson City. (See the headnote to “Letter from Mark Twain,” no. 69, for Clemens' practical reasons for writing about the schools at this time.)

Editorial Notes
1 The first section is “Winters' New House” (no. 70). A final section, “Concerning Undertakers,” is scheduled to appear in the collection of social and political writings in The Works of Mark Twain. It is reprinted in MTEnt , pp. 151–152.
Textual Commentary

The first printing appeared in the Virginia City Territorial Enterprise, probably on 12 February 1864. The only known copy of this printing, in a clipping in Scrapbook 3, p. 107, MTP, is copy-text. “Winters' New House” (no. 70) and this sketch constitute the first two sections of Mark Twain's letter from Carson City; for a third section, omitted here, see MTEnt , pp. 151–152. There are no textual notes.

[begin page 344]
An Excellent School

I expect Mr. Lawlor keeps the best private school in the Territory—or the best school of any kind, for that matter. I attended one of his monthly examinations a week ago, or such a matter, with Mr. Clagettexplanatory note, and we arrived at the conclusion that one might acquire a good college education there within the space of six months. Mr. Lawlor's is a little crib of a school-house, papered from floor to ceiling with black-boards adorned with impossible mathematical propositions done in white chalk. The effect is bewildering, to the stranger, but otherwise he will find the place comfortable enough. When we arrived, the teacher was talking in a rambling way upon a great many subjects, like a member of the House speaking to a point of order, and three boys were making verbatim reports of his remarks in Graham's phonographic short-hand on the walls of the school-room. These pupils had devoted half an hour to the study and practice of this accomplishment every day for the past four or five months, and the result was a proficiency usually attained only after eighteen months of application. It was amazing. Mr. Lawlor has so simplified the art of teaching in every department of instruction, that I am confident he could impart a thorough education in a short time to any individual who has as much as a spoonful of brains to work upon. It is in no spirit of extravagance that I set it down here as my serious conviction that Mr. Lawlor could even take one of our Miss Nancy “Meriden”explanatory note Prosecuting Attorneys and post him up so in a month or two that he could tell his own witnesses from those of the defense in [begin page 345] nine cases out of ten. Mind, I do not give this as an absolute certainty, but merely as an opinion of mine—and one which is open to grave doubts, too, I am willing to confess, now, when I come to think calmly and dispassionately about it. No—the truth is, the more I think of it, the more I weaken. I expect I spoke too soon—went off before I was primed, as it were. With your permission, I will take it all back. I know two or three prosecuting attorneys, and I am satisfied the foul density of their intellects would put out any intellectual candle that Mr. Lawlor could lower into them. I do not say that a Higher Power could not miraculously illuminate them. No, I only say I would rather see it first. A man always has more confidence in a thing after he has seen it, you know: at least that is the way with me. But to proceed with that school. Mr. Clagett invited one of those phonographic boys—Master Barry Ashim—to come and practice his short-hand in the House of Representatives. He accepted the invitation, and in accordance with resolutions offered by Messrs. Clagett and Stewart, he was tendered the compliment of a seat on the floor of the House during the session, and the Sergeant-at-Arms instructed to furnish him with a desk and such stationery as he might require. He has already become a reporter of no small pretensions. There is a class in Mr. Lawlor's school composed of children three months old and upwards, who know the spelling-book by heart. If you ask them what the first word is, in any given lesson, they will tell you in a moment, and then go on and spell every word (thirty-five) in the lesson, without once referring to the book or making a mistake. Again, you may mention a word and they will tell you which particular lesson it is in, and what words precede it and follow it. Then, again, you may propound an abstruse grammatical enigma, and the school will solve it in chorus—will tell you what language is correct, and what isn't; and why and wherefore; and quote rules and illustrations until you wish you hadn't said anything. Two or three doses of this kind will convince a man that there are youngsters in this school who know everything about grammar that can be learned, and what is just as important, can explain what they know so that other people can understand it. But when those fellows get to figuring, let second-rate mathematicians stand from under! For behold, it is their strong suit. They work miracles on a black-board with a piece of chalk. Witchcraft and sleight-of-handemendation, and all that sort of thing is foolishnessemendation to the [begin page 346] facility with which they can figure a moral impossibility down to an infallible result. They only require about a dozen figures to do a sum which by all ordinary methods would consume a hundred and fifty. These fellows could cypher a week on a sheet of foolscap. They can find out anything they want to with figures, and they are very quick about it, too. You tell them, for instance, that you were born in such and such a place, on such and such a day of the month, in such and such a year, and they will tell you in an instant how old your grandmother is. I have never seen any banker's clerks who could begin to cypher with those boys. It has been Virginia's unchristian policy to grab everything that was of any account that ever came into the Territory—Virginia could do many a worse thing than to grab this school and move it into the shadow of Mount Davidson, teacher and all.

Editorial Emendations An Excellent School
  sleight-of-hand (I-C)  •  slight-of-hand
  foolishness (I-C)  •  foolishnessness
Explanatory Notes An Excellent School
 Mr. Clagett] William H. (Billy) Clagett, an attorney whom Clemens first knew as a law student in Keokuk, Iowa, accompanied Clemens in 1861 to the Humboldt mining area. Clagett remained in that area and eventually represented Humboldt County in the territorial legislatures of 1862 and 1864, as well as in the state House of Representatives in 1864. Later he moved to Montana Territory, where he was elected delegate to the United States Congress in 1871 ( MTEnt , p. 226).
 “Meriden”] An unknown person using the pseudonym “Meriden” had recently attacked Clemens in print for using coarse humor and scandalous, contemptible expressions (“ ‘The Third House’ and Other Burlesques,” Virginia City Union, 30 January 1864, p. 2). The Storey County district attorney between September 1863 and November 1866 was Dighton Corson (Angel, History, p. 607). No evidence has been found to link Meriden or Clemens with Corson.